Skip to main content
Submitted by admin on Tue, 11/17/2026 - 10:35
Rwanda

PRESS RELEASE

Jambo ASBL strongly opposes the initiative formally announced in Vienna on 16 November 2026 by Germany, Austria, Denmark, Greece and the Netherlands to establish a return hub in Rwanda for migrants subject to enforceable return decisions. This choice raises serious legal, operational, humanitarian and diplomatic concerns in light of documented precedents and the state of fundamental rights in the country.

Jambo recognises that states have the sovereign authority to formulate and implement migration policies, in accordance with their international obligations. Our organisation challenges neither this principle nor the right of European governments to arrange the return of people who do not meet the legal requirements for residence. Our concern relates exclusively to the choice of Rwanda as the destination country.

This choice is all the more difficult to justify given two earlier experiences that should have served as warnings. Between 2013 and 2018, Israel transferred Eritrean and Sudanese asylum seekers to Rwanda under arrangements whose safeguards proved inadequate. UNHCR documented serious violations, including clandestine onward transfers to Uganda and risks of refoulement. In November 2023, the UK Supreme Court unanimously ruled the then-proposed transfer scheme to Rwanda unlawful, drawing in part on the Israeli precedent and shortcomings in Rwanda’s asylum system. The UK programme was eventually abandoned after £290 million had been paid to Rwanda, without a single asylum seeker being forcibly transferred under the scheme.

Human rights violations committed by the Rwandan government have been extensively documented. On 6 November 2026, the United Nations Human Rights Committee again expressed concern about detention in unofficial facilities, allegations of torture, restrictions on freedom of expression, and acts of intimidation targeting journalists, human rights defenders and political opponents in particular. In January 2026, during Rwanda’s Universal Periodic Review, Germany and the Netherlands themselves called for reforms concerning restrictions imposed on civil society organisations. These findings and recommendations directly call into question the consistency of the partnership now being contemplated.

The choice of Rwanda also raises a particularly troubling contradiction. If the country has been selected for the deterrent effect that its designation as a destination might have on migrants, the governments concerned must explain what underpins that deterrent effect. It would be profoundly cynical to seek to exploit restrictions on civil liberties or Rwanda’s socio-economic difficulties to discourage immigration, while simultaneously portraying the country as a safe destination offering credible prospects for integration. This question is all the more pressing against a backdrop of unemployment and severe pressure on purchasing power, as documented by official Rwandan statistics.

Beyond humanitarian considerations, such a partnership entails foreseeable legal, financial and diplomatic risks. Transferring people to a third country does not absolve European states of their obligations to protect against refoulement and uphold fundamental rights. It also entails political responsibility for the functioning of the institutions to whose care these individuals are entrusted. The Israeli and British experiences demonstrate that a diplomatic agreement, even one accompanied by formal safeguards, is no substitute for independent verification of their effective implementation. The safeguards announced — freedom of movement and access to employment, healthcare and justice — must therefore be subject to independent scrutiny in light of Rwanda’s political, institutional and socio-economic realities.

Jambo therefore calls on the five governments concerned to abandon their choice of Rwanda and to publish the legal, financial and institutional assessments that informed that decision. We also call on the European Commission to rigorously assess whether such an arrangement complies with EU law and the international obligations of its Member States.

The credibility of European foreign policy, particularly when it champions fundamental freedoms and the rule of law, also depends on consistency in its partnerships. No migration policy objective should lead governments to disregard risks already established by courts and international human rights mechanisms.

Norman Ishimwe Sinamenye

President of Jambo ASBL

Press contact: info@jamboasbl.com

Faire un don